| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 19 post(s) |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
4
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 20:02:00 -
[1] - Quote
So we can get perma-banned now for asking people to do a little song and dance now? When the "victim" wasn't punished for racism and death threats? When apparently encouraging someone to commit suicide is worth only a 3 month ban?
Yeah, nice priorities CCP. Successful witch hunt guys. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
4
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 20:08:00 -
[2] - Quote
Malcanis wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:So we can get perma-banned now for asking people to do a little song and dance? When the "victim" wasn't punished for racism and death threats? When apparently encouraging someone to commit suicide is worth only a 3 month ban?
Yeah, nice priorities CCP. Successful witch hunt guys. No you will not get permabanned for that. Unfortunatley you will be required to exercise your adult judgement on when you're on the threshold of taking it too far. If you feel yourself incapable of reliably doing that, then I suggest you err on the side of caution.
How can asking someone to sing songs and read wikipedia pages ever be too far? |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
5
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 20:15:00 -
[3] - Quote
Malcanis wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:Malcanis wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:So we can get perma-banned now for asking people to do a little song and dance? When the "victim" wasn't punished for racism and death threats? When apparently encouraging someone to commit suicide is worth only a 3 month ban?
Yeah, nice priorities CCP. Successful witch hunt guys. No you will not get permabanned for that. Unfortunatley you will be required to exercise your adult judgement on when you're on the threshold of taking it too far. If you feel yourself incapable of reliably doing that, then I suggest you err on the side of caution. How can asking someone to sing songs and read wikipedia pages ever be too far? Contract me all your ISK and stuff and we'll find out together.
Scamming is fine in this game. Asking someone to sing is fine. Apparently scamming and asking someone to sing isn't? |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
6
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 20:34:00 -
[4] - Quote
Malcanis wrote:Jarod Garamonde wrote:In general, where are we drawing the line, here? I answered this question a few pages page. The short answer is that the person controlling the situation has the responsibility to see that it doesn't go too far. I assume that you're sufficiently intelligent to determine when you're about to push someone over the line. This most specifically does not include in game actions: if someone goes into a screaming meltdown because you blew his ship up, then too bad for him. If you continue to interact with him and goad him for no reason other than to goad him, then you're in the red zone. Scam all you like. Gank all you like. Spy all you like. Awox all you like. Excercise judgement & discretion when rubbing salt into the wound afterwards. Is that so hard to understand?
Oh please, I'm sure some of my ganking victims have flew off the wall as hard as some bonus room victims did, why is it so different whether the cause of that was in game mechanics or having to sing 1 song too many in TS for their pixels? |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
11
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 21:22:00 -
[5] - Quote
Malcanis wrote:Lucas Kell wrote:Malcanis wrote:[quote=Lucas Kell][quote=Vance Armistice]Stuff.... More stuff Hope this helpsSorry that EVE criminal law isn't any more clear cut that real life.
The intention of the bonus room isn't reactions like Sokhar's, his was the extreme. For the most part people feel a bit silly that they were scammed and given the run around in a game where that is to be expected. At no point does Erotica or anyone else insult or threaten anyone (ie real harassment), nor do they even talk in a condescending tone, unlike your replies to most dissenting views. Hardly the same can be said of Sokhar. No one can predict reactions like Sokhar's, not to mention were totally omitting the part Sokhar plays in continuing to expose himself to terrifying, torturous song requests well after he knew he'd been scammed. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
11
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 21:25:00 -
[6] - Quote
Malcanis wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:
The intention of the bonus room isn't reactions like Sokhar's
Yes it was.
Then it's a spectacular failure considering that was the only reaction that extreme. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
13
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 21:37:00 -
[7] - Quote
Malcanis wrote:Danalee wrote:Malcanis wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:
The intention of the bonus room isn't reactions like Sokhar's
Yes it was. Bull. ****. And you know it. D.  They already had ALL of his stuff. They literally had nothing left to gain from him IN GAME. So yeah no, you're the bullshitter. And you know it. And CCP agree with me, so as previously advised, suck it up buttercup. I'm in 319- if you want to make something of it.
There's nothing to gain from many activities, just as a little trash talk in local has no gain but to wind other people up. And that's usually what the bonus room delivered, someone admitting they felt dumb but accepted it was their fault because of the nature of EVE. Sokhars reaction is the equivalent of that old video of a German kid smashing up his keyboard because he's losing at whatever FPS he's playing. No one can expect that nor be blamed for it when all that's lost is a few pixels and a bit of face. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
14
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 21:49:00 -
[8] - Quote
Toshiro Ozuwara wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:when all that's lost is a few pixels and a bit of face. The "it's just pixels" argument is fine to make if talking about your pixels. But if I got mine with GTC, or spending 300 hours mining, they may represent more than just "pixels" to me. I hate when people pull the "just pixels" crap in Eve, when we know full well people make massive time, energy and money commitments to be here. If you're carefree with your pixels, grand. Don't assume everyone feels as you do. Btw, give me your pixels, since they are "just a few pixels".
Well let me clarify. Maybe you have attachment to your pixels for the reasons you have stated, but nonetheless you are playing EVE, you know the nature of the game. You know if you contract everything you own out to someone there's a chance you won't get it back. So when that happens it is indeed unreasonable to fly off the wall like you've caught someone making death threats to your mother, whether the scammer has asked you to sing a song or not. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
16
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:01:00 -
[9] - Quote
Tyrant Scorn wrote:So let me get a stab at this...
Erotica1 and friends scam someone from all of his assets and his isk and made a recording of them trolling him on TeamSpeak while they are doing it. Keep in mind, the victim goes through the process of contracting all of his assets to the scammers and doing this willingly.
After an hour and 45 minutes the victim goes completely berserk and starts threatening the scammers with real life threats, he calls them names and at some point even goes as far as using racist terms such as the N word.
Mind everyone, Erotica1 and his friends stay completely cool and have done nothing out of the ordinary for ingame Eve Online standards. They are not responsible for other peoples stupidity and can not see into the future that their actions will set the victim off like this. But it is in no way their fault. Every man is responsible for what he says regardless. A scamming action is no valid reason for calling people the N word or threatening them in real life. There is no justification for any of what the victim said to them, period.
But now, from what I understand CCP faults Erotica1 and his friends for what they have done...
Is it me or did their morals drop down below zero on this ? I think the fact someone is using such language, in such a hostile way is far more offensive then what Erotica1 did. In fact, CCP nurtures scamming behavior... So who is at fault here and why ????
You've got it absolutely right. Lets look at what actually happened, Erotica scammed someone, that's acceptable in eve. For a little fun he plays a little wind up game, having the victim sing, arguably no worse than trash talking in local. Then Sokhar starts swearing, being racist and acting like a madman at Erotica simply for doing things that are perfectly allowed in the game. At no point does Erotica descend to Sokhar's level, remaining the professional scammer he was. Surely it is Sokhar who is the bad guy in this story, getting angry at Erotica for doing what people in eve do. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
19
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:11:00 -
[10] - Quote
Sipphakta en Gravonere wrote:Antisocial Malkavian wrote:Agreed. Sokhar is a racist! That doesn't mean he doesn't deserve the same protection as everybody else, usually laws and policies apply to everyone.
Pretty sure using racist language is against the rules. Erotica 1 broke no rules when he scammed. He broke no rules when he asked Sokhar to sing. Sokhar broke the rules first when he said racist things, when he threatened Erotica's mother. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
19
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:14:00 -
[11] - Quote
Salvos Rhoska wrote:ITT: A few people who seem to completely lack the faculty of comprehending what might entail "clear and extraordinary levels of real life harassment against players in the outside world."
To me that's finding out someones personal information or bombarding someone with abusive posts. It isn't asking someone to sing after they've been scammed in a game famous for its scamming. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
20
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:20:00 -
[12] - Quote
Salvos Rhoska wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:To me that's finding out someones personal information or bombarding someone with abusive posts. It isn't asking someone to sing after they've been scammed in a game famous for its scamming. I would agree. And that has not changed :)
Except it has since that's exactly what Erotica 1 has been banned for. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
22
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:30:00 -
[13] - Quote
Salvos Rhoska wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:Except it has since that's exactly what Erotica 1 has been banned for. How do you know what Erotica1 was banned for? Cite your source please.
He was banned for the bonus room, that should be pretty clear. I would hardly call what went on there the equivalent of finding out someones personal information. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
22
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:38:00 -
[14] - Quote
Vance Armistice wrote:Tyrant Scorn wrote:Vance Armistice wrote:Tyrant Scorn wrote:So what it all comes down to is that I can no longer gank people in WH space, because I might gank a thin skinned cry baby who goes all berserk on me and reports me to CCP... is that what's happening here now ? I heard that too...I think they are going to make it a thing in the next patch. No,not really I'm just messing with you. Take a breath...in..now...out... Repeat after me: "Unless I go completely outside the bounds of acceptable human behavior I will still be able to do all the things I currently enjoy doing in this game" That help? If you want examples of unacceptable human behavior listen to some E1 recordings. Who was unacceptable in that recording ? All I heard from the victim is N words, gutting peoples mother, threatening people... Who was crossing the line in that recording... you tell me... please, because I don't have a switch where I twist my morals around and allow myself to feel sorry for the victim. There is an "s" at the end of the word "recording" there are several. Exercise your due diligence and go find them, we don't have time to bring you up to speed.
Sokhars was the exception, not the rule. Most victims felt disgruntled but accepted they were scammed and given the run around. And as far as I can tell those bonus rooms would not be bannable, it's only because Erotica has been interpreted to have gone too far by continuing to ask for songs after Sokhar flipped out. I disagree that it was too far because it was Sokhar who acted unreasonably in response to being scammed. Further I do not approve of how personal you are getting over a minor disagreement over something in an online game, either you want a debate or you want insult throwing, decide. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
22
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:42:00 -
[15] - Quote
Prince Kobol wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:
Sokhars was the exception, not the rule. Most victims felt disgruntled but accepted they were scammed and given the run around. And as far as I can tell those bonus rooms would not be bannable, it's only because Erotica has been interpreted to have gone too far by continuing to ask for songs after Sokhar flipped out. I disagree that it was too far because it was Sokhar who acted unreasonably in response to being scammed. Further I do not approve of how personal you are getting over a minor disagreement over something in an online game, either you want a debate or you want insult throwing, decide.
So are you saying that so long as it only one person who has been humiliated or harassed then its okay?
If you read the rest of my post you'll see that while I admit Sokhars reaction was extreme it was not because I believe Erotica went too far. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
28
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:48:00 -
[16] - Quote
Vance Armistice wrote:
Please explain in detail the thought process behind asking another player to dribble mayo on their mouth and take a picture. Then explain why E1 got so upset when people found personal details about his purchasing habits from info he left in public. Then tell us about his peanutbutter fetish. Explain why he was too extreme to remain in GS and was kicked. Why does he get his kicks from humiliating others. Then tell us all why we should give a rat's ass about another random weirdo that got caught out there fapping to other's misery.
You can't ,can you? You have to stick to the talking points you were issued.
I didn't reply to this the last 3 or 4 times you posted it because I'm talking about Sokhar's bonus room as this seems to be the direct reason for Erotica's ban. I'm unfamiliar with the things you have posted, and considering how much has been made of the mayo incident I find it implausible that it actually happened considering this is the internet and the pictures have never popped up. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
28
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:49:00 -
[17] - Quote
Prince Kobol wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:Prince Kobol wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:
Sokhars was the exception, not the rule. Most victims felt disgruntled but accepted they were scammed and given the run around. And as far as I can tell those bonus rooms would not be bannable, it's only because Erotica has been interpreted to have gone too far by continuing to ask for songs after Sokhar flipped out. I disagree that it was too far because it was Sokhar who acted unreasonably in response to being scammed. Further I do not approve of how personal you are getting over a minor disagreement over something in an online game, either you want a debate or you want insult throwing, decide.
So are you saying that so long as it only one person who has been humiliated or harassed then its okay? If you read the rest of my post you'll see that while I admit Sokhars reaction was extreme it was not because I believe Erotica went too far. Fair enough, if you believe Sokhars reaction was extreme, but was not caused by any actions by Erotica, then what do you believe caused such an extreme reaction from Sokhar?
Thin skin and lack of understanding of the game he's playing. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
29
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 22:56:00 -
[18] - Quote
Prince Kobol wrote:
The game he was playing, I thought Eve was about shooting space pixels, I didn't realise it also involved being humiliated and then having a recording of it all placed on the internet.
Must of missed that part on the advertising, need to ask CCP to make a promo vid.
We've already gone over this, he was scammed and then given the run around for a little in TS, it's no worse than a trash talk in local. Plenty of others went through the same thing and didn't react like a lunatic because they understood being scammed and wound up is a possibility. |

Jebediah Phoenix
NEW ORDER DEATH DEALERS CODE.
29
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 23:03:00 -
[19] - Quote
olan2005 wrote: ok where has anyone said that the racism and threats where allowed. Also in your opinion did this not go beyond a scam . Think about it the scammers got all his assets and still continued . At that point was this still a scam
Have I gone beyond a gank if I trash talk in local? Having the guy sing a few songs is not much different. Plenty of things in this game are not done for any real gain. |

Jebediah Phoenix
The Conference Elite CODE.
33
|
Posted - 2014.03.28 23:35:00 -
[20] - Quote
Bael Malefic wrote:Jebediah Phoenix wrote:
Have I gone beyond a gank if I trash talk in local? Having the guy sing a few songs is not much different. Plenty of things in this game are not done for any real gain.
Trash talking after a fight is all about your ego. Personally, I find players who feel the need to do that to be weak. They are just like children on a playground, trying to paper over their own insecurity with posturing. It's a waste of time. As is responding to it. You say something repugnant enough while you are trash talking, you will find yourself wondering why that banhammer hit you so hard. Even if you personally can't understand. Seen people banned for stuff said/posted in local. And every time they acted surprised, as if they couldn't imagine why.
I'm never foul in local, I would never host a bonus room. But that doesn't mean I want light hearted banter banned, whether it be making someone sing in TS or trash talking in local. And when I say trash talking, I certainly don't mean anything nasty, I mean stuff like recommending a permit tank. |
| |
|